Finally, just what you've been searching for in the heart of Cayuga Heights. Located within a short walk to the elementary school and close to shopping, restaurants, coffee shop and services at Corner's Community. Easy access to public transportation. This 4 bedroom 2.5 bath home has been meticulously maintained and updated with a craftsman style flair. Oak floors in bright living room that opens to a formal dining. Kitchen with expansive granite counter space, updated maple cabinetry and custom interior shelving for all your storage needs. The breakfast bar is so convenient and it all opens to a family room and access to a two level deck overlooking a private yard with partial natural habitat(see documents for all the birds that have been spotted on the property or have flown over it while sellers have lived here). Primary suite spa like bath with gorgeous walk-in shower and radiant heat in the floor! Wait 'til you see the foyer/mudroom- it will delight you with light, function and craftsman details. The partially finished basement is perfect for hobbies, play, study and or exercise. Plenty of storage space as well. Over $170,000 in improvements including new siding, new roof, new heating, many new windows, new oak flooring...too many others to mention. Must see.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Warren Real Estate / Susan Lustick
$1,750,000 (USD)
Millstone Lane Area Single Family Home
Pending
110 Millstone Aurora, NY 13026
4 Bed
4.1 Baths
3564 sqft
MLS# IB411263
Magical home on 2.9ac on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake minutes from Aurora, NY-often called America's best small spa & wellness town. A winding road surrounded by fields of wildflowers greets you as you make your way to this property with 400 ft of lake frontage on a quiet cove great for a swim, sail or kayak. Enjoy eagles& osprey. Architecturally interesting, carbon-neutral home with irrigated landscaping & gardens, expansive out of door living spaces overlooking lake. Walls of glass, a mixture of soaring ceilings, lofts, wood & ultra modern living spaces. Large spaces for hobbies, workshops & or play. Flexible living areas can double as living or bedroom. Year round dock, boat moorings, and trailer lake access. Additional all wood party barn/garage with an apartment over it. Geothermal heat/cooling & electric car charging all powered by a solar array. A must see to appreciate quality details both inside & out. A year round lake side home that really does have it all!
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Warren Real Estate / Susan Lustick
$1,570,000 (USD)
Lansing Station Area Single Family Home
Pending
290 Algerine Road Lansing, NY 14882
4 Bed
3 Baths
2816 sqft
MLS# R1615838
Once-in-a-Lifetime Opportunity on Cayuga Lake — Lansing’s Hidden Gem! This is the property you've been waiting for — and may never see again. Set in a coveted year-round neighborhood in Lansing, this spectacular 4.85-acre estate boasts an unparalleled 350+ feet of level lake frontage with an effortless walk right to the water’s edge. Whether you're dreaming of a serene lakeside retreat or planning a generational family compound, this property offers endless potential and breathtaking beauty.The land is a stunning mix of professionally landscaped irrigated gardens, open meadow, and lush lawn, all perfectly framing the panoramic lake views. There's plenty of space to build a charming cottage right on the waterfront or design your dream forever home with the lake as your backyard. Atop the property sits a meticulously maintained, ranch-style home with expansive views of Cayuga Lake. Pristine 4-bedroom, 3-bath residence with primary on the main level, handicap adaptable, multiple sunrooms, custom cherry kitchen and a 2 car garage plus a 3 car garage-ideal for car enthusiasts, builders and or collectors. Must be seen to appreciate all this property has to offer. Negotiations delayed until Aug 21st at 1pm.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Warren Real Estate / Susan Lustick
$685,000 (USD)
Ithaca Area Multi-Family Home
Pending
1 Maplewood Road Ithaca, NY 14850
8 Bed
0 Baths
4830 sqft
MLS# R1618836
A unique opportunity to own 8 one bedroom apartments with winter lake views. Cut down some trees and you'd have lake views year round. Apartments are all designed the same, each with a mirror image of the other. Four on upper level and four apartments on ground level each with a door to the exterior. Parking enough for about 1.5 cars per apartment. 205 is currently used as an office but could be a 9th apartment. Seller has provided a washer and dryer for use by the tenants at no additional cost. Tenants pay electric, seller pays propane and general maintenace costs. This property has never been available on the market prior to now. Negotiations will be delayed until Friday, July 18th, 2025, NOON!
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Warren Real Estate / Susan Lustick
$589,000 (USD)
Shalebrook Sub Area Single Family Home
Pending
1 Perry Lane Ithaca, NY 14850
3 Bed
2.1 Baths
2257 sqft
MLS# R1636450
Welcome to Shalebrook, a hidden gem on West Hill. This special lane, lined with curbs and winding gracefully through the hillside, offers a rare sense of privacy and community. Though many don’t even know it exists, the location couldn’t be more convenient—just minutes from the hospital, downtown Ithaca, Cornell, and Ithaca College.
The property’s greatest treasures are the views and the landscaping, which have been designed for beauty with minimal upkeep. Facing west, the home overlooks a wide grassy meadow, a picturesque barn in the distance, and the backdrop of Cornell’s hillside. Ithaca Falls can even be spotted, while sunrises, sunsets, and moonrises create a new painting in the sky each day. Outdoor living is at its best here with a multi-tiered deck and gazebo strung with bistro lighting—the perfect place to dine al fresco while the sky shifts through colors.
Inside, the home has been impeccably maintained and thoughtfully designed. A two-story foyer with skylights fills the entry with natural light, while oak hardwood floors flow into a spacious living room with two distinct seating areas, one centered around a wood-burning fireplace. The kitchen is efficient yet stylish with quartz counters, tiled backsplash, and a functional island, along with distant views from the sink.
The main-level primary suite is a retreat of its own, complete with a walk-in closet and a spa-like bath. Upstairs are two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a flexible loft space ideal for a home office. The fully finished lower level, with eight-foot ceilings, offers endless options for a family room, hobby area, office, or play space, along with abundant storage.
Move-in ready and full of pride of ownership, this home is as special as its setting. The next fortunate owner will discover just how rare Shalebrook truly is. Be sure and check out the 3D tour to get an in person experience. Homes like this don’t come along often, especially on this tucked-away lane! Experience it in person at the open house this Saturday Sept 13th, 11:00 to 1:00. Offers being reviewed on 9/16.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Warren Real Estate / Susan Lustick