Susan's Featured Listings

Some or all of the listings below are provided by the Ithaca Village Office office.
$399,000 (USD)
Active

Lodi Area Single Family Home

Active

8450 N Maple Street Lodi, NY 14860

5 Bed
2 Baths
2968 sqft
MLS# R1638788
Virtual Tour
Welcome to the Preacher’s Retreat- a stunning Victorian built in 1873 as the manse for the Lodi Presbyterian Church, now lovingly restored and decked out in a hip, eclectic style. This one-of-a-kind home perfectly blends historic charm with modern conveniences and sits in the heart of the Finger Lakes, centrally located between Seneca and Cayuga wine trails and just minutes from Watkins Glen, Ithaca, and some of the region’s most beautiful state parks for swimming, hiking, and boating.

Step inside and be wowed by soaring ceilings, period details, and thoughtful updates throughout. Recent renovations (2021) include: all-new electrical and plumbing, high-efficiency dual-fuel forced air system, new roof and gutters with guards, and brand-new water systems (jet pump, well pump saver, storage tank, and multistage filtration). The kitchen was rebuilt in period style, while the bathrooms exude spa-like luxury, think curb-less shower, dual rainfall heads, clawfoot tub, and double sinks in a massive upstairs bath. A new laundry was added to the first floor, and mini-splits were installed upstairs for comfort.

The home is sold fully furnished and decorated, an eclectic, funky, yet romantic mix that makes it move-in ready. Outside, enjoy a large, level yard, paneled privacy fence, and hog wire fence with vining plants creating a living green screen.

Whether you’re dreaming of a unique full-time residence or a standout short-term rental on the Wine Trail, this property is ready to deliver. Just bring your suitcase and settle in.

Come experience it for yourself! Step inside this romantic Victorian to see just how effortlessly historic charm and modern style come together.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Warren Real Estate / Kathleen "Kate" Seaman
$399,000 (USD)
Active

Village/Trumansburg Area Single Family Home

Active

36 Bradley Street Ulysses, NY 14886

4 Bed
2 Baths
2052 sqft
MLS# R1658747
Virtual Tour
Vernacular farmhouse with Craftsman influences offers four bedrooms, including one conveniently located on the main level, and two full bathrooms—one on the main floor and one on the second floor. Classic farmhouse simplicity is complemented by subtle Craftsman details, creating a home that feels both timeless and welcoming. Featuring a central eat-in kitchen with convenient laundry room just off to the side & a walk-in pantry that provides generous storage. Two porch-like spaces on opposite sides of the house create natural light fill spaces to enjoy the large 1/2 acre Village lot, along with a large back deck, create an easy, organic flow to the outdoors. Storage galore with oodles of closets starting with the large mudroom entry that has 3 large closets. Many more closets, some walk-in throughout the house. Original built-in hall organizer cupboards upstairs, including a built-in ironing board. Below, a full basement with walk-up exterior access offers abundant storage and flexible space, completing a home with real functionality. Covered front entry and back deck made of easy care Trex decking. Natural gas boiler for constant, comfortable hot water baseboard heat, fully insulated as per energy audit recommendations. Sellers reserve the right to set an offer review date.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Warren Real Estate / Allison Hogue
$310,000 (USD)
Active

Covert Area Land

Active

5234 Oak Harbor Rd- Lot #10 Covert, NY 14886

Bed
0 Baths
sqft
MLS# R1623583
Build your dream home in Oak Harbor, a private 12-lot enclave perched above Cayuga Lake in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Lot 10 offers 1.9 wooded acres with lake views and shared ownership of 300 feet of pristine lakefront, including a private dock, boat lift, nature trails, picnic area, and playground. Adjacent to the 800-acre Taughannock Falls State Park, this property is surrounded by natural beauty, abundant wildlife, and peaceful privacy.

Oak Harbor is ideally situated just minutes from downtown Ithaca, Cornell University, Ithaca College, and the charming Village of Trumansburg. The community allows for the construction of a guest house, perfect for a home office or extended family suite, offering flexibility in a highly desirable location.

HOA fees vary by year depending on planned maintenance and are currently about $1200 annually and cover maintenance of the shoreline, common areas, stair access to the lake, and private road, making lake life more enjoyable and hassle-free. The newer shared dock and boat lift provide added convenience and savings over marina fees.

Whether you’re planning a year-round residence, seasonal escape, or investment property, Lot 10 at Oak Harbor delivers the best of both worlds: seclusion and natural surroundings with a friendly community and easy access to amenities. A rare opportunity with lake access, lake views, building flexibility, and close proximity to wine trails, parks, and restaurants.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Warren Real Estate / Kathleen "Kate" Seaman
$299,000 (USD)
Pending

Newfield Area Land

Pending

169 Irish Hill Road Newfield, NY 14867

Bed
0 Baths
1176 sqft
MLS# R1662323
Virtual Tour
Discover 133 tranquil acres of forested land, including two adjoining parcels (28 acres and 105 acres) that directly border Newfield State Forest. This remarkable property features a hardwood forest and abundant wildlife, including white-tailed deer, black bear, wild turkey, and over 135 bird species. The property provides year-round recreation: hiking, cross-country skiing, snowshoeing, wildlife observation, and excellent access for outdoor enthusiasts, all within your own private sanctuary. Whether you're envisioning a private retreat or custom homesite, this land offers the privacy, scale, and natural character you seek.
This 133-acre property directly borders Newfield State Forest, positioning you at the gateway to over 17,000 acres of contiguous public conservation land. Step from your property directly into an interconnected network of protected forests, including the 1,552-acre Newfield State Forest, the 4,200-acre Cornell Arnot Teaching and Research Forest, and the 11,237-acre Connecticut Hill Wildlife Management Area, without crossing a single property line. Located on scenic Irish Hill Road just 11 miles south of Ithaca, you'll enjoy seclusion while maintaining convenient access to Cornell University and downtown amenities. While you own 133 acres, you live and recreate as if you own 17,000+. This is the kind of opportunity that doesn't come along often.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Warren Real Estate / Colleen Cowan