Susan's Featured Listings

Some or all of the listings below are provided by the Ithaca Village Office office.
$480,000 (USD)
Active

Ulysses Area Land

Active

0 E Seneca Road Ulysses, NY 14886

Bed
0 Baths
sqft
MLS# R1677669
16 plus acres of prime real estate in the Village of Trumansburg offering an exciting opportunity for builders, developers, investors, or anyone looking to create a dream property in one of the area’s most desirable communities. With over 500 feet of road frontage, municipal water and natural gas available, with development potential, this expansive parcel provides a rare combination of size, and accessibility.
Ideally located in the heart of Trumansburg and within the sought after Trumansburg School District, this property offers endless possibilities. Explore the potential for a thoughtfully planned residential development, a custom estate, or a private retreat with room to grow, all while enjoying the convenience of village living. The generous acreage allows for flexibility in design and vision, whether you are considering multiple homesites, new construction, or a one of a kind property tailored to your lifestyle.
For builders and developers, the road frontage, available utilities, and central location make this an especially compelling opportunity in a market where quality land is increasingly hard to find. For buyers dreaming of building, this is a beautiful blank canvas with space for a custom home, gardens, outdoor living, recreation, and future possibilities.
Enjoy the charm and convenience of Trumansburg, with nearby shops, restaurants, schools, parks, and access to the Finger Lakes lifestyle. Close to Taughannock Falls, the Black Diamond Trail and Frontenac Park make this a great location for those who love the outdoors. Opportunities of this scale within the Village do not come along often. Bring your plans, your builder, and your imagination, and discover the potential of this exceptional 16 plus acre parcel.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Listed By: Jill Burlington, Warren Real Estate
$479,000 (USD)
Active

Ithaca City Area Single Family Home

Active

521 S Cayuga Street Ithaca City, NY 14850

4 Bed
4 Baths
2732 sqft
MLS# R1713837
Virtual Tour
Authentic character, beautiful craftsmanship, and far more living space than you might expect from the street! Designed in 1923 by noted Ithaca architect John M. Wilgus, this distinctive Craftsman home is just blocks from the Commons in a quiet, sweet neighborhood. It offers FOUR levels of living space, FOUR bedrooms, and FOUR full baths.

Original Craftsman details have been beautifully preserved, including rich oak floors and chestnut millwork, a distinctive Mission-style staircase, plaster walls, original light fixtures, period hardware, and clawfoot soaking tubs. The traditional floor plan offers comfortable bedrooms and an abundance of spaces for living, working, hobbies, guests, and entertaining.

The walk-up third floor adds two finished rooms and a full bath, creating wonderful bonus space for an art studio, home office, playroom, guest space, or creative retreat. The partially finished, [exceptionally] dry basement provides even more flexibility for a workshop, workout room, office, hobbies, and storage.

One of the home’s most charming features is the covered front porch, reached by a unique bridge over the lower level and complete with a porch swing—the sellers’ favorite place for morning coffee, evening wine, and watching the sunset. Off the kitchen, a screened porch provides another inviting spot for meals, gatherings, or simply enjoying the seasons.

Street parking is convenient and typically easy to find directly in front of the house. A pre-inspection is available from the sellers for added peace of mind. With its remarkable original details, flexible living spaces, and walkable location near downtown Ithaca, this is a home whose warmth and character simply cannot be recreated.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Listed By: Kathleen "Kate" Seaman, Warren Real Estate
$465,000 (USD)
Active

Ithaca Town Area Single Family Home

Active

203 Pine Tree Road Ithaca Town, NY 14850

4 Bed
2.1 Baths
2214 sqft
MLS# R1689171
Virtual Tour
Calling all artists, makers, dreamers, and creatives! Discover East Hill cottage living with an income apartment and an inspiring 2,100+ square foot art studio/workshop ready for your next masterpiece.
First time on the market in 38 years, this former stop along Ithaca's art trail is ready for its next chapter. The c1933 main house blends timeless character w/modern updates, featuring hardwood floors, wood staircase, an IKEA maple kitchen, sun-filled sunroom addition with vaulted ceilings, and updated 1.5 baths. The heart of the home is bright & connected, with the living/dining room open to both the kitchen and sunroom with openings that invite natural light to flood thru-out. The galley kitchen offers abundant cabinetry & counter space, plus newer stainless appliances. A convenient half bath and laundry complete the first floor, while upstairs you'll find 2bedrooms plus full bath. The primary bedroom is a cozy retreat with vaulted ceilings, skylight, and exposed brick chimney accents. Heading outside, the deck overlooks an ornamental pond, framed by cheerful yellow irises. Mature trees create a private, woodsy setting that feels worlds away, yet you're only minutes from Cornell and downtown Ithaca via the East Ithaca Recreation Way via nearby TCAT bus stop. And then there's the studio. More than 2,100 Sq Ft. spread across 3 distinct spaces offering endless possibilities for painters, ceramicists, sculptors, photographers, woodworkers, musicians, fiber artists—or anyone seeking room to create. High ceilings, generous workspace, and a separate 1-bedroom, 1-bath setup provide flexibility for guest quarters, a home office, gallery space, or creative retreat. The attached 2-bed apartment, recently vacated for easy showings, has generated $1,400 per month plus separate utils, offering income potential to support your passions. Ample parking, ramp access to the main house, and all municipal services including natural gas & water/sewer add convenience. Create-Exhibit-Gather-Live. Rarely does a home come along that so beautifully blends character, creativity, and practicality. Let your imagination take root here in the heart of East Ithaca.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Listed By: Christine "CJ" DelVecchio, Warren Real Estate
$450,000 (USD)
Active

Danby Area Single Family Home

Active

54 Bald Hill Road Danby, NY 14883

6 Bed
3 Baths
2438 sqft
MLS# R1712194
Virtual Tour
Set against an open landscape with sweeping views, this fully renovated two-unit property offers flexibility, space, and income potential just minutes from Ithaca. Both apartments have been thoughtfully updated with renovated kitchens and baths and modern finishes. The larger Unit 1 features hardwood flooring throughout, while Unit 2 offers durable LVT flooring. Both units are currently vacant, offering an appealing opportunity for an owner-occupant, investor, or buyer looking to establish new rental terms. Unit 1 was most recently rented for $2,200 per month, including utilities, while Unit 2 was most recently rented for $1,800 per month, including utilities.

Outside, an expansive wraparound deck takes full advantage of the property’s setting, with plenty of room for outdoor dining, entertaining, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings and wide-open views. A 2.5-car garage provides generous space for parking, storage, hobbies, or equipment.

With two updated living spaces, strong rental history, and both units currently vacant, the property offers immediate flexibility for its next owner. Live in one unit and rent the other, establish new leases for both, or create a multigenerational living arrangement with separate spaces under one roof.

Conveniently located within easy reach of Ithaca while offering the space and scenery of a more rural setting, 54 Bald Hill Road is a versatile property with options for both homeowners and investors.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Listed By: Elizabeth Thompson, Warren Real Estate